New ideas for Craft Beer Profitability

This spring and early summer were tough for Ontario craft breweries: Cash reserves were low or depleted from winter, the new LCBO system was missing orders and payments, and summer ramp-up.

The challenge for most craft breweries remains, to achieve profitability. That's a tough problem. My approach on tough problems is to read and speak to experts for new insights and ideas. I spent several days reading about 80 pages of relevant material online. Here's what I found that was compelling:

*The setup: The U.S. Brewers Association highlighted the challenges of an industry gone ex-growth in its annual report: In 2025 U.S. craft beer experienced a 5% decline in production, worse than the 3.9% decline in 2024. Some 60% of craft breweries reported a decline. Microbreweries were hit worst, with an 8.9% decline, while brewpubs did relatively better with only a 1.7% decline. Closures outpaced openings for the second year in a row at 481 closures to 300 openings. The BA said its outlook is “cautiously optimistic.” Based on my experience as an investment analyst, having heard many CEOs of troubled companies use the same words, I would remind you that hope is not a plan. If you want your results to change, you must change your actions.

*Solution 1 - Focus over Flash: Here’s an insightful analysis by the Beer CPA, aka Laura Mikeworth of Charlotte, North Carolina. “The breweries that are surviving, even thriving, have discovered the power of focus,” says Mikeworth. Fewer SKUs, fewer suppliers, fewer ingredients, more focused marketing and more bulk purchasing will result in better quality, clearer brand and greater expertise. This is a very detailed analysis including real-world cases from breweries in North Carolina, Vermont and California. The author says that moving from 20 SKUs to 8-10 can result in 40% reduction in operating complexity, and can boost your bestsellers by 50%.

*Solution 2 - Know Your Data: Quality beer is no longer sufficient to protect your business, says Jeremy King co-founder of CraftedERP, a Denver, Colorado software provider, in this data-focused article. Most breweries don’t know their numbers and can not break down their Cost of Goods including labour, can’t identify margin erosion before end of quarter, don’t know margins for different package formats, and don’t know which SKUs are killing cash flow. I recognize that he wants to sell you an ERP system to solve these problems, but I think his analysis is correct. There are many methods to get on top of your numbers, and a good ERP is one approach. Here’s what Jeremy says happens if you don’t lead and manage with accurate, timely data: Pricing is all guesswork, production planning is reactive, you chase volume instead of profit, leadership decisions are based on debates about opinions instead of facts and beer strategy becomes emotional. "Our fans love it,” is the excuse for continuing to brew a money-losing beer.

*Solution 3 - Align with Today’s Trends: Value is the number one trend for consumers in 2026, writes Joshua Bernstein, author of five books on craft beer, in a thorough analysis at SevenFiftyDaily. With consumers under pressure due to inflation, creating a value line of products is essential. Gen-Z needs to be a focus, and they do drink beer when they can afford it. Taproom experience is central and standards have risen. “Simply being the local craft brewery with a food truck isn’t enough.”

For people who learn better by listening than by reading, I used Notebook LM, a Google AI tool, to create a 33-minute podcast summarizing these documents. (You may have to wait for the file to load or click to download.) The AI podcast hosts are entertaining, enthusiastic and generally accurate. Please let me know how you liked it.

Link to podcast

Previous
Previous

Three Questions on Profitability with Slake Brewing

Next
Next

Escaping the Commodity Trap