Escaping the Commodity Trap

Most of my posts have been directed to craft breweries with a focus on taproom hospitality and food service. Production breweries, which focus on the distribution of beer, face a tough challenge:

How to escape the commodity trap?

Part of the challenge is that a large distribution business is much more complex, which prevents nimble and quick responses to market dynamics. Yet most production breweries do not have scale anywhere near that of the big national or global breweries which dominate in distribution. You’re stuck in the middle.

That’s a difficult position to be in. I think the commodity angle may be a rising risk for a few of the big craft breweries now riding a growth wave through grocery, convenience and Costco sales. High growth and big exposure can make a successful craft brewery look to some like a corporate giant, straining the relationship you had with some of your original customers.

Yet, commodity businesses are around us everywhere. There are many ways to produce above-market growth. Here are a few ways to explore escaping the commodity trap:

*Trade into a niche: When you’re in a commoditizing market, segmentation is a ticket out because it tells customers exactly who you are for and (now the scary bit) who you’re not for. Think of cleaning products. Not a lot of differentiation. Not much room for profit except by volume. Now think of environmental or green cleaning products. That’s a niche with big differentiation. And it earns a premium. But the niche looks too small for P&G to bother with.

How many niches are there for beer?

Off the top of my head, how about high-alc, low-alc, no-alc, super IPAs, session IPAs, light lagers, fruity beers, dark beers, experimental beers, beers for older people, beers for younger people, beers for foodies, beers for wine-drinkers, beers for whiskey drinkers, German beers, Belgian beers, English ales, beers for athletes, beers with fresh ingredients, beers with local ingredients, beers with exotic ingredients, etc.

Here’s the challenge: You can only pick one niche. You have to say no to the idea of being a general-purpose brewery. You have to turn your back on some customers and you will initially shed volume in order to focus on your niche. Sounds scary, but it’s not if you understand the risk of commoditization. If you are stuck in the middle in a commodity business, you’ve got nothing to tell customers about why you are special. And gradually, customers will realize you have nothing special to offer. Innovation in a niche category, even a category that seems small, is the key to long-term growth and margin. All profitable growth markets look small at the beginning.

Previous
Previous

New ideas for Craft Beer Profitability

Next
Next

A Brewer’s Perspective on Cost of Goods