My sense is that many craft beverage producers are rethinking their business this winter. For some, it is a time to expand. For others, it is a time to consider the sale or closing of the business. It may be helpful to gain an insight on the current market for breweries, cideries and distilleries.
Observations:
*Large number of businesses for sale. I have seen about 20 southern Ontario breweries, cideries and distilleries for sale in the past year, some on real estate sites, some on business for sale sites, some with business brokers. Others are quietly for sale without a public listing.
*Repeated price cuts. Several of the listings on MLS and broker sites show repeated price cuts. Some have cut prices as many as four times, discounting as much as 70% from the first listed price.
*High days on market. Small business sales typically can take 12 months. A small number of listings have reappeared over a two-three year period.
*Several listings terminated. A large number of listings have been terminated, unsold, after 5-8 months.
*Several businesses have closed. Four of the listed businesses have closed. I am aware of five other breweries that closed without listing.
*Few transactions. Only one of the publicly-listed businesses appears to have been sold, after the listing was terminated.
*Few profitable, growing businesses available. Given that 74% of craft breweries in Ontario are losing money and none of the listed businesses are described as profitable, there appears to be an absence of growing, viable craft beverage businesses for sale.
*Six-10 active buyers. I am aware of several prospective buyers actively considering acquisitions. Most are already in the craft brewing industry, some are private investors.
Conclusions: Itβs a buyerβs market. Many if not most breweries are actually for sale even if they are not listed because either the founders or the financial backers are exhausted and open to offers.
There is little demand for money-losing breweries. The few buyers in the market appear to have built sustainably profitable businesses. They donβt want to risk what they have created by taking on an acquisition that could reverse their profits. If you want to sell your business for a fair value, you need to generate profits. Fix before selling.
Many business owners wait until it is too late to try to sell. Some of the businesses for sale appear to be insolvent or to have such high debts or other internal challenges as to be virtually unsellable. Address your business challenges before it is too late.
Growing, profitable breweries can achieve premium valuation. There are few growing, profitable breweries. Because they are rare and they represent much lower risk to prospective buyers, they should be able to achieve premium valuation.
There is room for optimism. I do not believe that this industry is structurally flawed. Many breweries struggle, yes, and for business owners who are willing to manage their business and change their operations, there are paths to growth and profitability. A handful of Ontario craft breweries are achieving very high growth, with LCBO all-channel sales growth of 19%-50% last year mainly due to increased convenience and grocery sales. Others are delivering 20%+ sales growth and high net margins based on a solid hospitality offering. One high-growth category is non-alcohol beer, with 19% annual sales growth since 2019. And Costco is looking to sell more local Ontario craft beer. Even though per capita beer consumption has declined in Canada for 50 years, your sales can continue to grow if the hospitality, the food and the service are strong.