My sense is that this winter, a lot of breweries wonβt survive. Later, when the Intagram posts and the hand-wringing start, the usual excuses about the craft beverage business will be trotted out: COVID changed the industry, the economy is tough, young people donβt drink as much, etc. And true, these factors contribute to a difficult industry, but they skirt the real issues.
Iβve worked with brewery owners for several years and with entrepreneurs for many years. These are the root causes of failure that I see:
1) Undercapitalization/Excessive Debt: Craft beer is a capital-intensive, low-margin industry. Given that nature, it doesnβt make sense to operate on a shoe-string budget. The business requires a heavy investment in brewing equipment, inventory, kitchen equipment, space, staffing and working capital. If you canβt raise the equity, rethink your plans. Heavy loan obligations reduce your margin of error. Just because banks are willing to lend millions, does not mean it is a good idea. I know a couple of farm breweries that are debt-averse. They are profitable, they grow slowly, upgrading their equipment and the scale of their business at the speed of cash generation. The late Harvard Prof. Clayton Christensen would have supported that approach. He urged tech innovators to be βpatient for growth, impatient for profit.β Most investors, most breweries and most tech startups take the opposite approach: they chase growth, thinking profits will come later. Most fail.
2) Excessive Overhead/Bad Leases: Whatever you buy, build or lease, you have to support financially. I remember visiting one of the most beautiful, well-engineered regional breweries in Ontario. The facility was overbuilt. It was impossible for the original owners to get a return on that investment. The standard Key Performance Indicator (KPI) for rent and other occupancy cost is 9-11% of total revenue. I have seen leases well above double that. Guaranteed to never make money.
3) Failure to Understand the Role of the Entrepreneur: Michael Gerber wrote βThe E-Myth,β the best book on small business, back in 1986. Gerber explodes the myth of entrepreneurship. Your job as business owner is not to brew the best beer. Your job is to train people to do that to your standard and to work on the business to document all steps and processes, as if you were scaling up to become the next McDonaldβs. And then grow the business to greater stability. It is impossible to do everything yourself, so you have to grow your skills from those of a skilled artisan to those of a CEO by working on the business, not in it. You must document, automate and delegate. If you donβt take on this CEO role, you will never get off the hamster wheel and you may come to feel that your business owns you.
4) Failure to Understand the Business You Are in: Gussie Busch, the man who created the modern Budweiser empire from the 1950s through the β70s, famously said, βMaking friends is our business.β Meaning, Anheuser-Busch was selling more than beer, they were selling a part of the modern social fabric, at sports events, with family, at the corner bar. Many brewery owners focus only on the beer, neglecting the many things customers are buying, such as a commitment to the community, a quiet moment, a noisy party, a good meal, a reward for hard work, a lively date, a thrilling game night. Start with hospitality. Most breweries undervalue this.
5) Failure to Adapt: The craft beverage industry is dynamic. Owners should expect to continue evolving their business. In the investment world, we say the stock market gives you free information every day, if you pay attention. That light lager that has gradually become so popular? The market is telling you something. Taproom empties by 7pm? Diners are telling you something about your food or lack thereof. Look for the free market feedback. Analyze what works in your business and build on the unexpected hits. Re-work or eliminate the unexpected failures. Do this often.
6) Failure to Face Difficult Decisions: Many brewery owners know the problems in their business. The unpopular beer that the brew team likes to make. The employee that doesnβt care. The rent thatβs too high. The upaid taxes. Greg Taylor, CEO of Steam Whistle, told me the problem is often that owners wonβt make the tough decisions needed to solve these problems. Some of these problems, unaddressed, have the risk of becoming big problems. Try getting through a day without rationalization. Confront these issues immediately: the problem employee, the problem product, the broken process, the overdue taxes.
These are tough ideas to consider. Ask yourself: Am I confronting the realities of my business or am I hiding from them? Who can help me to grow my skills and to increase accountability throughout the business?