I’ve had several bad beer experiences in the past few months that remind me how poorly some craft beverage makers execute their craft. Here’s a quick rundown:
* Montreal festbier: served flat and hazy (see picture);
* Montreal Kentucky common: served with butyric acid off-flavour;
* Toronto multiple beers at one location with phenolic off-flavours;
* Southern Ontario multiple beers at one location with bacterial infection;
* North of Toronto multiple ciders at one location with butyric acid or acetobacter.
Nobody who plans to stay in business can afford to let their beer be inconsistent, infected or filled with off-flavours. Yet it happens. Here are a few steps every brewery needs to implement:
1. Educate your staff to know what your beers should taste like, what the most common off-flavours are and how to recognize them. Staff who don’t drink do not get a free pass. I have heard the “I’m sorry, I don’t drink beer” excuse from too many servers when I ask about a beer. Your job as owner is to ensure that servers and all employees know your products and contribute to quality control.
2. Create a sensory panel of employees and or friends of the brewery who meet regularly and who sample, under proper conditions, every product you produce. Do not depend on your head brewer to be the sole judge of your beer. The likelihood of bias is too high and the dependence on one set of taste buds sets you up for failure. Craft brewers often look sideways at big macro brewers, but you can be sure that they take quality seriously. Craft brewers can take a page from Miller’s longstanding quality control mandate, which required sampling “every tank, every shift, every day.” You must also develop discipline on what to do if a beer is outside the expected flavour range but still acceptable (maybe call it a special edition or blend it) and rigorous discipline on when to dump a batch.
3. Make quality a priority across the business. This will affect the ingredients you buy, the acceptable shelf life of ingredients in stock, the processes and standards that must be adhered to in brewing, packaging, shipping and serving.
Here are a few resources to ensure that you reduce the risk of making, selling and serving bad beer:
* BJCP List of Off-Flavours
* BA Guide to Building a Sensory Panel
* Siebel Institute’s Richard Dubé: Eliminate Contaminants (video)
* Siebel Institute Off-flavour kit
Think about it: When was the last time you had a real stinker of a craft beer? And compare that to when was the last time you had an off-beer from a major manufacturer?
Can We Get Serious About Beer Quality?
Previous
Previous
New Data: Why 60% of Craft Breweries Lose Money
Next
Next